[ S T ] ShPTK-TVP 100 treads to the Supertest
Дата: 02.12.2021 20:00:58
churchill50: I'm having trouble seeing what there is to suggest this
tank...
At least it's not OP I guess, but this is definitely too far in the opposite direction in my opinion. Survivability is crap. 1150 HP and thin armor. 65mm of armor frontally is just enough to not be HE penned by a decent amount of tanks, but that's the only good news there.
Mobility is decent. Good power/weight, decent hull traverse speed. Turret traverse speed is a bit low, but that's to be expected. Top speed is limited though. 55kmh isn't great. Plus we don't know the terrain resistances, which can really affect the mobility.
Firepower is... really underwhelming. Pen is good, but that's about it. Low alpha, mediocre reload/DPM (somewhere in the 2200-2500 DPM range maxed out I believe, which is bad given the alpha), bad accuracy, dispersion values are mediocre (besides turret rotation, which is good), only 6 degrees of gun depression, horrible shell velocity. It does have a decent HE shell, but that's not going to make up for everything else.View range is crap, and we don't know the camo values. It can't really play up close because it's paper and lacks alpha. It can't play at range because of the bad accuracy, dispersion, shell velocity, and overall underwhelming firepower. But, this is the beginning of Supertest. So hopefully it will be stronger and more well-defined (instead of not fitting in any role) by the end of Supertest.
At least it's not OP I guess, but this is definitely too far in the opposite direction in my opinion. Survivability is crap. 1150 HP and thin armor. 65mm of armor frontally is just enough to not be HE penned by a decent amount of tanks, but that's the only good news there.
Mobility is decent. Good power/weight, decent hull traverse speed. Turret traverse speed is a bit low, but that's to be expected. Top speed is limited though. 55kmh isn't great. Plus we don't know the terrain resistances, which can really affect the mobility.
Firepower is... really underwhelming. Pen is good, but that's about it. Low alpha, mediocre reload/DPM (somewhere in the 2200-2500 DPM range maxed out I believe, which is bad given the alpha), bad accuracy, dispersion values are mediocre (besides turret rotation, which is good), only 6 degrees of gun depression, horrible shell velocity. It does have a decent HE shell, but that's not going to make up for everything else.View range is crap, and we don't know the camo values. It can't really play up close because it's paper and lacks alpha. It can't play at range because of the bad accuracy, dispersion, shell velocity, and overall underwhelming firepower. But, this is the beginning of Supertest. So hopefully it will be stronger and more well-defined (instead of not fitting in any role) by the end of Supertest.
[ S T ] ShPTK-TVP 100 treads to the Supertest