T110's Zen-like Inner Core.
Дата: 22.08.2015 22:15:22
The_Chieftain: Loose, you're misinterpreting my opposition to
electronic observation systems. I would rather have them than not.
Where I draw the comfort line is the exclusive reliance upon such
equipment at the cost of the possibility of using a human head to
do it. The Merkava video does not show any inherent disadvantage to
a heads-out option. Close-in spaces are traditionally a blind spot,
and I am left to wonder what happens to that tank's wingman. I
would be more concerned by things like being able to spot missile
threats, such as the Israelis suffered in 2006, where
back-scratching by the wingman is not a possibility. It would not
hamper the tank's combat capability to both have the electronics
and be able to stick a head out. I am confounded by your
statement that T14's TC can be in combat with his hatch open. The
point is to be able to react quickly to contact. How is that TC
supposed to respond to a target to his right? In almost every other
tank dating back to Sherman, I can grab the TC's override and
immediately swing onto the right azimuth without taking my eyes off
the target, Unless T14's TC is willing to decapitate himself, he
cannot do that. Even if he just ducked down, he still can't even
traverse right without closing the hatch. My fist contact was
tracer fire heading for me from my 3 o clock. I didn't waste time
closing the hatch, just ducked down and yelled ''scan right.'
I'm sorry, I do not think that T14 could reliably react as
quickly. I suspect the Syrian experience is a reflection of
equipment limitation. Soviet tanks do not seem to have cared much
for the option of an open protected position for some reason, There
was a hot sniper spot in Mosul, Yarmouk Traffic Circle. They
decided to park us in the middle of the place to keep an eye on
things. We were no so daft as to keep our heads out as we sat
stationary. We did, however, go open protected, where we still had
350 degree vision by the simple expediency of turning our heads,
Fortunately, because the circle was a fairly open area, with a bit
of space between the multi-story buildings and the road, the
relative inability to look up wasn't a problem. Unless I've missed
something, Syrian tankers are not given that option, they have
all-or-nothing protection. Again, I cannot stress enough
that I am not condemning T14's layout. I am merely observing that
the layout loses some situational awareness in trade for whatever
benefits you get.
T110's Zen-like Inner Core.














