Why do Some Argue Against Skill Based MM?

SimplyPzB2, on May 27 2021 - 21:54, said: Now lets say 1 more purple player and 1 less red player had been chosen.  There are two options.   Option 1 : unbalanced - will be what selected 40% of the time under random mm, but never under sbmm:  This battle is inherently unfair to all players, as it has put both good players on one team, thus ensuring team 1 is bored, while team 2 gets sealclubbed. skill            team 1         team   2                    Mr.10k         Mr. 2k purple            1                   0 red                13                14   Option 2 : Balanced - will be what selected 60% of the time under random mm, but 100% of the time under sbmm:  This battle is inherently fair to all players because the playing field is level at the start of the battle.  Both teams have an equal chance to win.  skill            team 1         team   2                    Mr.10k         Mr. 2k purple            0                   1 red                14                13 - Sidenote:  you keep saying that Mr.10k will ALWAYS have the worse team.  Look at Option 2.  His team is NOT worse.  It's dead equal.  And under real world teams, where there is a mix of colors, quite  often Mr.10k will get the ever so slightly better team (but never a very better team)... - simplton...  


NeatoMan, on May 27 2021 - 18:37, said: Don't use numbers with him.  He always gets it wrong