Why do Some Argue Against Skill Based MM?

DeviouslyCursed:  SBMM will see whatever metric is it looking for: WTR, WN8, WR, etc. The category 'red' is irrelevant to it. So if one red is 2K WTR, and another is 1K WTR, it will not see them the same, and will put more of the lower WTR reds onto the purple player's team to balance. Since we are comparing 10K vs 2K, the SBMM will move approximately 8K difference worth of extra WTR to the 2K person's team. In other words, if all 28 reds that need to be assigned were 14 2K players and 14 1K players, the 10K guy would get 11 1k and 3 2K, and the 2K player would get 3 1K and 11 2K. Each team ends with 27K total WTR. 10K's teammates = 17K WTR2K's teammates = 25K WTR 10K's teammates < 2K's teammatesYes, even if they are all red.