Proof SBMM is Unfair

ElDerpomatic, on May 21 2021 - 22:29, said: You need to stop drinking WG's grape cool aid.  All players do NOT have the same opportunity to win.  How can it be a players actions that give an advantage/disadvantage when the team composition is nowhere close to being balanced?  I'll give you a couple examples from a couple months ago.  In one tier 9-10 game my teams heavies consisted of a Kranvagn and an ST-II while the other teams heavies were both Chieftans (not platooned together).  That right there is a disadvantage before the game even starts.  In a tier 6 game my team's heavies were both KV-2®'s while the other teams heavies were both O-I's.  Both of our KV-2®'s were destroyed by the O-I's, neither of which took any damage during the game.   There is no advantage for the teams I was on in both examples.  We lost both of those games 13-0 and 15-0.  I can only imagine you are going to argue that the examples I gave do not prove a disadvantage, and anyone who can conclude that clearly either A) Works for WG, B) Has little to no actual understanding of how broken MM is, or C) Both A and B.